Radicalism, past, present and future
Over recent years, it seems ‘radical’ has become a dirty word. In the wake of the anniversary of 1968, and with books and films galore about the romance and failures of revolutionary life and thought, it seems we’re comfortable with radicalism as an object of nostalgia, but less willing to understand its contemporary legacy – and its trivialisation.
Culture Wars is exploring radicalism – past, present and future – in an attempt to understand a lived tradition as well as how certain ideas filter through the culture. Having focused on past ‘Radical Thinkers’ and the legacy of 1968, touring from Iran to Haiti, investigating the role of ideology and demise of the traditional Left, we turn towards two contemporary variants: ‘political Islam’ and the environmentalist movement. These reviews and essays constitute a critical investigation of what shapes contemporary attitudes towards the future.
The End of Left and Right?
A Battle in Print essay from the Battle of Ideas 2008The end of Left and Right, if it has occurred, needs to be taken seriously. It amounts to no less than the collapse of a way of looking at, and doing, ‘politics’.
The Gates of Eden are rusting!
A Battle in Print essay from the Battle of Ideas 2008Don Eales recalls the political power of popular song, and asks where the voices of challenge and dissent are today.
Snow in Istanbul
Photoessay impression: Istanbul, and Snow by Orhan Pamuk (Faber)Once people internalise the ideology of passivity and infectiveness, they cease to be able to understand themselves as properly political subjects.
Organised defeat? - here comes everybody
Here Comes Everybody: The Power of Organizing Without Organizations, by Clay ShirkyShirky and other digital evangelists argue the rise of social media is actually a severe challenge to the elite’s hegemony and authority.
Mummy dearest
Sex and Society in Early 20th Century Spain: Hildegart Rodriguez and the World League for Sexual Reform, by Alison SinclairHildegart’s tragedy may well come to occupy a niche of bizarre but instructive prominence in the intellectual history of the twentieth century.
Participation nation
Democracy, by Paul Ginsborg (Profile Books)As a humble citizen participating in one of these schemes, you cannot have faith that every individual will respect your views, since those who make the final decisions are not accountable to you.
Communist kitsch without conviction
Photoessay: a visit to Memento Park, Budapest, HungaryIs a work of art that forges its content out of the everyday, and shows its epic potential, not infinitely preferable to fantasy tales from Middle Earth?
Psychoanalyse the psychoanalysts?
Zizek! (2005), directed by Astra TaylorDirector Astra Taylor has done a fine job with an impossible brief. Zizek is a hard man to film, and it is even harder to convey his ideas. The movie manages both; its form belies its sophistication.
For the love of God
Spinoza and Politics, by Etienne Balibar (Radical Thinkers III)Aside from the moral posture led by Government, the general attitude towards ‘radical views’ today looks like the self-indulgent smile given to a small puppy naughtily walking all over the new family sofa.
Zizek, partially digested
The Indivisible Remainder: On Schelling and Related Matters (Verso 2007); In Defence of Lost Causes (Verso 2008); Violence (big ideas) (Profile 2008)Zizek is wondering how we can capture the progressive potential that was recognised in the working class when the working class no longer has a political existence.
The excess of the left in Iran
Rebels with a cause: the failure of the left in Iran, by Maziar Behrooz (IB Tauris)His history reveals that the left failed precisely because of an excess of ideas and fractious allegiances to every brand of revolutionary Marxism going: Leninism, Stalinism, Trotskyism, Maoism and Castroism.
Thermal mass housing
Garbage Warrior (2007), directed by Oliver HodgeA welcome breath of fresh air in a climate that collocates any discussion about alternative approaches to the environment with pointless schemes such as ‘offsetting’ your carbon footprint.
What does the ruling class do when it rules?
What does the ruling class do when it rules? Goran Therborn (Verso Radical Thinkers III Series)It is key that Therborn’s historicisation of the class character of the state remains valid, even if we are forced to consider how the situation now looks thirty years on.
On Ideology
On Ideology, by Louis Althusser (Verso Radical Thinkers III series)For all his talk of developing Marxism, Althusser is intent on rebuilding a new, overly deterministic system, where ideology, and in particular the educational state apparatus take on primary roles.
The Emergence of Social Space
The Emergence of Social Space: Rimbaud and the Paris Commune, by Kristin Ross (Verso Radical Thinkers III Series)Ross constructs a highly persuasive argument that the 1871 commune, with Rimbaud’s poetry at the centre, should be observed from a spatial critique, with some startlingly comprehensible results.
