World Development
World Development today is a contested concept, and one that provokes debate across the board. Culture Wars is bringing together reviews of books and the arts, to engage with everything from globalisation to slum cities, from consumerism to international aid.
Questions dealt with throughout these reviews include: following massive economic growth from China and India, are we seeing a new distribution of power on the world stage? How should we respond to the perceived costs of development such as global warming and the erosion of communities? And what are the best models for growth?
Chinese normality
Reflections on China Design Now at the V&A, LondonChina Design Now announced modern China as a global cultural presence, and offered its exhibits as a cultural parallel to its economic advancement since the 1980s.
The People’s Republic is learning presentational skills
China: the truth about its human rights record, by Frank Ching (Rider Press)As for Tibet, I was in Beijing and other cities in the period of the recent confrontation in Lhasa and elsewhere. The general opinion of taxi drivers was that the economic development of Tibet should have made this a non-issue and still might.
Ideal growth?
The Dragon and the Elephant: China, India an the New World Order, by David Smith (Profile) and Adam Smith in Beijing: Lineages of the 21st Century, by Giovanni Arrighi (Verso)There is no reason to assume this ideological vacuity will last: if nothing else, the class struggle that economic development will produce means that history is not yet dead.
I wanna be like you
What does China think?, by Mark Leonard (Fourth Estate)What really emerges through Leonard’s discussion is how familiar rather than ideologically different China is. The concerns of China’s ‘New Left’ – the environment, inequality, welfarism – are very similar to those of the Western left.
Speed dating on progress
The Battle for Progress, LIFT festival, Southbank Centre, London, 28 June 2008‘India has been successful in producing the Tata car to replace the rickshaws that many people have to depend on for transport. The Indian people want cars not rickshaws. Now we’re bringing their rickshaws to central London. What’s that about? We should be happy for the Chinese and the Indians.’
A superficial balance
China's New Confucianism: Politics and Everyday Life in a Changing Society, by Daniel A Bell (PUP)Like pretty much everywhere else on the planet nowadays, China is undergoing a cultural malaise triggered by the end of its recent ideology.
Savage civility
Wolf Totem, by Jiang Rong - translated by Howard Goldblatt (Hamish and Hamilton)Rong is dual spokesman: Outer Mongolian to the Chinese and Chinese to everybody else, not caught between fact and fiction but navigating a path between the two roles.
Environmentalism’s fig leaf
The Ethics of Climate Change: right and wrong in a changing world, by James Garvey (Continuum)We are asked to engage with Garvey’s view of the world as culprits. And as culprits, we are asked to stop what we are doing, and ‘give’ back to the poor what is theirs by some kind of right. In this relationship, the poor are like puppets that Garvey uses to act out a kind of morality play to elicit our sympathy – or guilt - for his cause.
Up to the gods
The Good Soul of Szechuan, The Young Vic, LondonIf there are parallels to be drawn with modern China, they are not morally simple. It’s interesting that the Young Vic has gone for a version of the play in which Shui Ta’s success rests on his heroin empire, in case tobacco doesn’t place him clearly enough beyond today’s moral pale. The child who was rummaging through bins for food is now employed – but the tobacco factory has given him a cough. Which is worse? Which is better?
Urbanisation without industrialisation
Planet of the Slums, by Mike DavisExcremental surplus, Davis argues, is the primordial urban contradiction. Even eight generations after Engels’ depiction of latrines in working class Manchester, shit still cakes the lives of the urban poor—‘a virtual objectification of their social condition, their place in society’, Davis quotes another urban theorist.
In search of eco-sin redemption
Last Chance to See, by Douglas Adams and Mark CarwardineThere is just one small problem for greens who think detesting humanity is laudable: they are members of the human race too. This means that, at some level, they must despise themselves.
Putting the hippies on the payroll
Green Capitalism: Manufacturing Scarcity in an Age of Abundance, by James HeartfieldEveryone has gone green. Even reprobate oil corporations have stopped funding the ‘global warming sceptics’, as they retool their operations to cash in on the bonanza of carbon-trading. Bewildered by the sudden desertion of their corporate allies, a few isolated libertarians fight a rearguard action against the green tide.
Cynical capitalism, cynical anti-capitalism
How an unloved system survives by default, and how its would-be critics condemn us to more of the sameIn the run-up to Christmas last year, German churches and trades unions joined forces to protest against the loosening of the country’s traditionally restrictive opening hours for shops. Berlin’s city administration, run by Social Democrats and reformed Communists, had passed an amendment allowing shops in the capital to open every Sunday in December, despite objections in terms of both religious tradition and the perceived interests of shop staff.
Is there a new global working class?
ICA, London, 20 November 2007The answer to the title of a debate at the Institute of Contemporary Arts (ICA) ‘Is there a new global working class’ is ‘yes.’ So you can stop reading now!
We’re all part of the Machine
Fast Food Nation (2006), directed by Richard LinklaterDespite the film’s didacticism, it isn’t a left-wing polemic. It’s a riff on the book - not a celluloid equivalent of it. It’s not an expose, jumping up and down and shouting. In fact it’s a film whose argument has more in common with Fritz Lang’s Metropolis than with the work of Michael Moore.
